HC-1 HC-1 The Board
HC-1.1 HC-1.1 Principle
HC-1.1.1
All
Bahraini investment firm licensees must be headed by an effective, collegial and informed Board of Directors ('the Board').January 2011HC-1.2 HC-1.2 Role and Responsibilities
HC-1.2.1
All directors must understand the Board's role and responsibilities under the Commercial Companies Law and any other laws or regulations that may govern their responsibilities from time to time. In particular:
(a) The Board's role as distinct from the role of the shareholders (who elect the Board and whose interests the Board serves) and the role of officers (whom the Board appoints and oversees); and(b) The Board's fiduciary duties of care and loyalty to theinvestment firm licensee and the shareholders (see HC-2.1).January 2011HC-1.2.2
The Board's role and responsibilities include but are not limited to:
(a) Approving and reviewing at least annually the overall business performance and strategy for theinvestment firm licensee ;(b) Reviewing regularly the implementation of the strategy and operational performance;(c) Causing financial statements to be prepared which accurately disclose theinvestment firm licensee's financial position;(d) Monitoring management performance;(e) Reviewing regularly the level of risk;(f) Approving and reviewing at least annually systems and controls framework (including policies);(g) Convening and preparing the agenda for shareholder meetings;(h) Monitoring conflicts of interest and preventing abusive related party transactions;(i) Assuring equitable treatment of shareholders including minority shareholders; and(j) Setting out clearly and reviewing on a regular basis who has authority to enter the licensee into contractual obligations.January 2020
January 2011HC-1.2.3
With respect to Subparagraph HC-1.2.2(j), the Board should set a materiality threshold so that contractual obligations above this set threshold are regularly reported to the Board. In setting the materiality threshold, the Board will consider the financial impact the contractual obligation may have in relation to its capital.
January 2011HC-1.2.4
The directors are responsible both individually and collectively for performing these responsibilities and must have sufficient expertise as a Board to understand the important issues relating to operation and control of the
investment firm licensee . Although the Board may delegate certain functions to committees or management, it may not delegate its ultimate responsibility to ensure that an adequate, effective, comprehensive and transparent corporate governance framework is in place. This statement must be clearly communicated to Board members andsenior management .January 2011HC-1.2.5
When a new director is inducted, the chairman of the Board, or the licensee's legal counsel or compliance officer, or other individual delegated by the chairman of the board, should review the Board's role and duties with that person, particularly covering legal and regulatory requirements and Module HC (see also HC-4.3.1).
Amended: January 2012
January 2011HC-1.2.6
The
investment firm licensee should have a written appointment agreement with each director which recites the directors' powers and duties and other matters relating to his appointment including his term, the time commitment envisaged, the committee assignment if any, hisremuneration and expense reimbursement entitlement, and his access to independent professional advice when that is needed.January 2011HC-1.2.7
The Board should adopt a formal Board charter or other statement specifying matters which are reserved to it, which should include but need not be limited to the specific requirements and responsibilities of directors.
January 2011Additional Guidance
HC-1.2.8
In assessing the
licensee's strategic plans (see Paragraph HC-1.2.2), the CBB would expect the Board to address thelicensee's current and future aspirations with respect to its position in the market place, its size, products, value and other key aspirations that would be considered important by investors. Furthermore, the Board should demonstrate that it is able to identify proactively and understand the significant risks that the licensee faces in achieving its business objectives. A description of thelicensee's strategy should be included in the annual financial statements.January 2011HC-1.2.9
In assessing the management framework (see Paragraph HC-1.2.2), the CBB would expect the Board to have effective policies and processes in place for:
(a) Ensuring a formal and transparent Board nomination process;(b) Appointingsenior managers , and ensuring that they have the necessary integrity, technical and managerial competence, and experience;(c) Overseeing succession planning, and minimizing undue reliance on key individuals;(d) Reviewing keysenior management and Board remuneration packages and ensuring such packages are consistent with the corporate values and strategy of thelicensee and encourage prudent risk taking;(e) Monitoring and evaluating management's performance in implementing agreed strategy and business plans, and ensuring appropriate resources are available; and(f) Approving budgets and reviewing performance against those budgets.January 2011HC-1.2.10
In assessing the systems and controls framework (see Paragraph HC-1.2.2), the CBB would expect the Board to be able to demonstrate that the
licensee's operations, individually and collectively:(a) Are measured, monitored and controlled by appropriate, effective and prudent risk management systems commensurate with the scope of thelicensee's activities. These should pro-actively identify as well as monitor risk. The systems should produce information on a timely basis, and in a form and quality appropriate to the needs of the different recipients;(b) Are supported by an appropriate control environment. The risk management and financial reporting functions must be independent of business lines and must be run by individuals not involved with the day-to-day running of the various business areas; and(c) Make effective use of the work of internal and external auditors.January 2011HC-1.3 HC-1.3 Composition
HC-1.3.1
The Memorandum and Articles of Association of
Bahraini investment firm licensees must adequately set out procedures for the appointment, removal and retirement ofdirectors .January 2011HC-1.3.2
The Board should have no more than 15 members, and should regularly review its size and composition to ensure that it is small enough for efficient decision-making yet large enough to have members who can contribute from different specialties and viewpoints. The Board should recommend changes in Board size to the shareholders when a needed change requires amendment of the
investment firm licensee's Memorandum of Association.Amended: October 2014
January 2011HC-1.3.3
It is not expected that every Board member is proficient in all areas, but collectively the Board is expected to have the required expertise. CBB also expects Board members to undertake relevant training on a regular basis to help them fulfill their responsibilities as
Directors .January 2011HC-1.3.4
Potential
non-executive directors should be made aware of their duties before their nomination, particularly as to the time commitment required. The Nominating Committee should regularly review the time commitment required from eachnon-executive director and should require eachnon-executive director to inform the Committee before he accepts any Board appointments to another company. One person should not hold more than three directorships in public companies in Bahrain with the provision that no conflict of interest may exist, and the Board should not propose the election or reelection of any director who does.January 2011HC-1.3.5
To fulfil its responsibilities outlined in Section HC-1.2, the Board of
Bahraini investment firm licensees must periodically assess its composition and size and, where appropriate, reconstitute itself and its committees by selecting newdirectors to replace long-standing members or those members whose contributions to thelicensee or its committees is not adequate.January 2011HC-1.3.6
To demonstrate compliance with Rule HC-1.3.5, the Board should be able to demonstrate that it regularly considers (e.g. every one or two years) the mix of executive, non-executive and independent non-executive
Directors , and skills and experience, that it requires. See also Paragraph HC-1.3.2.January 2011HC-1.3.7
A Board member may have a maximum of two Directorships of financial institutions inside Bahrain. However, two Directorships of
investment firm licensees would not be permitted.Investment firm licensees may approach the CBB for exemption from this limit where the Directorships concern financial institutions within the same group.Amended: April 2013
January 2011HC-1.3.8
The appointment of Board members is conditional on the approval of the CBB (See Section AU-1.2).
January 2011HC-1.4 HC-1.4 Decision Making Process
HC-1.4.1
The Board must be collegial and deliberative, to gain the benefit of each individual director's judgment and experience.
January 2011HC-1.4.2
The chairman must take an active lead in promoting mutual trust, open discussion, constructive dissent and support for decisions after they have been made.
January 2011HC-1.4.3
The Board must meet frequently but in no event less than four times a year. All directors must attend the meetings whenever possible and the directors must maintain informal communication between meetings.
January 2011HC-1.4.4
Individual board members must attend at least 75% of all Board meetings in a given financial year to enable the Board to discharge its responsibilities effectively (see table below). Voting and attendance proxies for board meetings are prohibited at all times.
Meetings per year 75% Attendance requirement 4 3 5 4 6 5 7 5 8 6 9 7 10 8 Amended: April 2011
January 2011HC-1.4.4A
The absence of Board members at Board and committee meetings must be noted in the meeting minutes. In addition, Board attendance percentage must be reported during any general assembly meeting when Board members stand for re-election (e.g. Board member XYZ attended 95% of scheduled meetings this year).
Added: April 2011
HC-1.4.4B
In the event that a Board member has not attended at least 75% of Board meetings in any given financial year, the
investment firm licensee must immediately notify the CBB indicating which member has failed to satisfy this requirement, his level of attendance and any mitigating circumstances affecting his non-attendance. The CBB shall then consider the matter and determine whether disciplinary action, including disqualification of that Board member pursuant to Article 65 of the CBB Law, is appropriate. Unless there are exceptional circumstances, it is likely that the CBB will take disciplinary action.Added: April 2011
HC-1.4.5
To meet its obligations under Rule HC-1.4.3 above, the Board should meet preferably no less than four times per year. The CBB recommends that meetings should take place once every quarter to address the Board's responsibilities for management oversight and performance monitoring. Furthermore, Board rules should require members to step down if they are not actively participating in Board meetings. Board members are reminded that non attendance at board meetings does not absolve them of their responsibilities as directors. It is important that each individual director should allocate adequate time and effort to discharge his responsibilities. All Directors are expected to contribute actively to the work of the Board in order to discharge their responsibilities and should make every effort to attend board meetings where major issues are to be discussed.
Investment firm licensees are encouraged to amend their Articles of Association to provide for telephonic and videoconference meetings. Participation in board meetings by means of video or telephone conferencing is regarded as attendance and may be recorded as such.Amended: April 2011
January 2011HC-1.4.6
At least half the Board meetings of
Bahraini investment firm licensees in any twelve-month period must be held in the Kingdom of Bahrain.January 2011HC-1.4.7
The chairman must ensure that all directors receive an agenda, minutes of prior meetings, and adequate background information in writing before each Board meeting and when necessary between meetings. All directors must receive the same Board information. At the same time, directors have a legal duty to inform themselves and they must ensure that they receive adequate and timely information and must study it carefully.
January 2011HC-1.4.8
The Board must maintain adequate records of its meetings, such that key decisions and how they are arrived at can be traced.
January 2011HC-1.5 HC-1.5 Independence of Judgment
HC-1.5.1
The Board must ensure that it has sufficient non-executive and
independent non-executive directors (in addition to its Chairman), in order to provide sufficient independent scrutiny of management.January 2011HC-1.5.2
In the case of a
Bahraini investment firm licensee , which is part of an overseas group, where there is sufficient independent scrutiny of the operations of the firm on a group wide basis, the CBB will consider exempting the licensee from the independence requirements of Paragraph HC-1.5.1.January 2011HC-1.5.3
Every director must bring independent judgment to bear in decision-making. No individual or group of directors must dominate the Board's decision-making and no one individual should have unfettered powers of decision.
January 2011HC-1.5.4
Executive directors must provide the Board with all relevant business and financial information within their cognizance, and must recognise that their role as a director is different from their role as an officer.January 2011HC-1.5.5
Non-executive directors should be fully independent of management and should constructively scrutinise and challenge management including the management performance ofexecutive directors .January 2011HC-1.5.6
At least half of an
investment firm licensee's Board should benon-executive directors and at least three of those persons should beindependent directors. (Note the exception for controlled companies in Paragraph HC-1.6.2 and for possible exemption under Paragraph HC-1.5.2).January 2011HC-1.5.7
The chairman of the Board should be an
independent director so that there will be an appropriate balance of power and greater capacity of the Board for independent decision making.Amended: January 2012
January 2011HC-1.5.7A
The chairman and/or deputy chairman must not be the same person as the CEO.
Added: January 2012HC-1.5.8
The Board must review the independence of each director at least annually in light of interests disclosed by them. Each
independent director must provide the Board with all necessary and updated information for this purpose.Amended: April 2021
January 2011HC-1.5.9
To facilitate free and open communication among
independent directors , each Board meeting should be preceded or followed with a session at which onlyindependent directors are present, except as may otherwise be determined by theindependent directors themselves.January 2011HC-1.5.10
Where an independent director has served three consecutive terms on the board, such director will lose his/her independence status and must not be classified as an independent director if reappointed.
Added: April 2021HC-1.5.11
Where a Chief Executive Officer of an
investment firm licensee , who is also a Board member, no longer occupies the CEO position, whether due to resignation, retirement or termination, his/her Board Membership must also be immediately terminated.Added: April 2021HC-1.6 HC-1.6 Representation of all Shareholders
HC-1.6.1
Each director must consider himself as representing all shareholders and must act accordingly. The Board must avoid having representatives of specific groups or interests within its membership and must not allow itself to become a battleground of vested interests. If the company has a
controller (or a group ofcontrollers acting in concert), the latter must recognise its or their specific responsibility to the other shareholders, which is direct and is separate from that of the Board of directors.January 2011HC-1.6.2
In
investment firm licensees with acontroller , at least one-third of the Board must beindependent directors . Minority shareholders must generally look toindependent directors' diligent regard for their interests, in preference to seeking specific representation on the Board.January 2011HC-1.6.3
In
investment firm licensees with acontroller , both controllers and other shareholders should be aware ofcontrollers' specific responsibilities regarding their duty of loyalty to theinvestment firm licensee and conflicts of interest (see Chapter HC-2) and also of rights that minority shareholders may have to elect specific directors under the Company Law or if theinvestment firm licensee has adopted cumulative voting for directors. The chairman of the board or other individual delegated by the chairman of the board should take the lead in explaining this with the help of company lawyers.Amended: January 2012
January 2011HC-1.7 HC-1.7 Directors' Access to Independent Advice
HC-1.7.1
The Board must ensure that individual directors have access to independent legal or other professional advice at the
investment firm licensee's expense whenever they judge this necessary to discharge their responsibilities as directors and this must be in accordance with theinvestment firm licensee's policy approved by the Board.January 2011HC-1.7.2
Individual directors must also have access to the
investment firm licensee's corporate secretary, who must have responsibility for reporting to the Board on Board procedures. Both the appointment and removal of the corporate secretary must be a matter for the Board as a whole, not for the CEO or any other officer.January 2011HC-1.7.3
Whenever a director has serious concerns which cannot be resolved concerning the running of the
investment firm licensee or a proposed action, he should consider seeking independent advice and should ensure that the concerns are recorded in the Board minutes and that any dissent from a Board action is noted or delivered in writing.January 2011HC-1.7.4
Upon resignation, a
non-executive director should provide a written statement to the chairman, for circulation to the Board, if he has any concerns such as those in Paragraph HC-1.7.3.January 2011HC-1.8 HC-1.8 Directors' Communication with Management
HC-1.8.1
The Board must encourage participation by management regarding matters the Board is considering, and also by management members who by reason of responsibilities or succession, the CEO believes should have exposure to the directors.
January 2011HC-1.8.2
Non-executive directors should have free access to theinvestment firm licensee's management beyond that provided in Board meetings. Such access should be through the Chairman of the Audit Committee or CEO. The Board should make this policy known to management to alleviate any management concerns about a director's authority in this regard.January 2011HC-1.9 HC-1.9 Committees of the Board
HC-1.9.1
The Board must create specialised committees when and as such committees are needed. In addition to the Audit Committee described elsewhere in this Module, these may include an Executive Committee to review and make recommendations to the whole Board on company actions, or a Risk Committee to identify and minimise specific risks of the
investment firm licensee's business.January 2011HC-1.9.2
The Board should establish a corporate governance committee of at least three independent members which should be responsible for developing and recommending changes from time to time in the
investment firm licensee's corporate governance policy framework.Amended: January 2012
January 2011HC-1.9.3
The Board or a committee may invite non-directors to participate in, but not vote at committee meetings so that the committee may gain the benefit of their advice and expertise in financial or other areas.
January 2011HC-1.9.4
Committees must act only within their mandates and therefore the Board must not allow any committee to dominate or effectively replace the whole Board in its decision-making responsibility.
January 2011HC-1.9.5
Committees may be combined provided that no conflict of interest might arise between the duties of such committees.
Amended: July 2012
January 2011HC-1.9.6
Every committee should have a formal written charter similar in form to the model charter which is set forth in Appendix A of this Module for the Audit Committee.
January 2011HC-1.10 HC-1.10 Evaluation of the Board and Each Committee
HC-1.10.1
At least annually the Board must conduct an evaluation of its performance and the performance of each committee and each individual director.
Amended: January 2012
January 2011HC-1.10.2
The evaluation process must include:
(a) Assessing how the Board operates, especially in light of Chapter HC-1;(b) Evaluating the performance of each committee in light of its specific purposes and responsibilities, which shall include review of the self-evaluations undertaken by each committee;(c) Reviewing each director's work, his attendance at Board and committee meetings, and his constructive involvement in discussions and decision-making; and(d) Reviewing the Board's current composition against its desired composition with a view toward maintaining an appropriate balance of skills and experience and a view toward planned and progressive refreshing of the Board.January 2011HC-1.10.3
While the evaluation is a responsibility of the entire Board, it should be organised and assisted by an internal Board committee and, when appropriate, with the help of external experts.
January 2011HC-1.10.4
The Board should report to the shareholders, at each annual shareholder meeting, that evaluations have been done.
January 2011HC-1.11 HC-1.11 Annual Board Review and Certification
HC-1.11.1
The Board must assess and document each year whether the internal corporate governance processes that it has implemented have successfully achieved their objectives, and consequently whether the Board has fulfilled its responsibilities for directing and monitoring the overall conduct of the
licensee's affairs.January 2011HC-1.11.2
[This Paragraph was deleted in January 2022].
Deleted: January 2022
Amended: October 2012
January 2011HC-1.11.3
[This Paragraph was deleted in January 2022].
Deleted: January 2022
January 2011HC-1.11.4
[This Paragraph was deleted in January 2022].
Deleted: January 2022
January 2011HC-1.11.5
The Board's review should cover the following specific matters:
(a) That the Board has reassessed thelicensee's objectives and plans, and has reviewed thelicensee's corporate strategy document;(b) That the Board has reassessed thelicensee's overall risk profile, and its mapping of risks and the control environment put in place to meet those risks. The Board must comment whether the control environment remains effective and appropriate;(c) That the Board has assessed thelicensee's internal controls, to confirm that these are based on established policies approved by the Board and provide reasonable assurance of the integrity and reliability of its financial records;(d) That the Board has assessed whether adherence to established internal limits and controls was continuously monitored;(e) That the Board has assessed that all new (or material changes to) significant policies and products introduced by thelicensee since the last Board certification were appropriately reviewed and approved at the time;(f) That the Board has assessed that management and staff have complied with thelicensee's corporate code of conduct (see Paragraph HC-2.2.4); and(g) That in the period under review, the Board had received and reviewed the external auditor's management letter within six months of the (previous) financial year end, together with comments on the letter and proposed actions, from thelicensee's audit committee and senior management.January 2020
January 2011HC-1.11.6
[This Paragraph was deleted in January 2022].
Deleted: January 2022
January 2011