• CA-3.10 CA-3.10 Wakalah

    • Introduction

      • CA-3.10.1

        This Section sets out the minimum capital adequacy requirement to cover the risk of losing invested capital arising from an Islamic bank licensee entering into asset-side financing contracts or transactions that are based on the Shari'a rules and principles of Wakalah.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.2

        An Islamic bank licensee assumes the role of a principal (Muwakkil) and appoints the customer as agent (Wakil) to carry out a specified set of services or act on its behalf. This Section is applicable to both restricted and unrestricted Wakalah financing.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.3

        Wakalah is a contract of agency whereby one person contracts to perform any work or provide any service on behalf of another person. Businesses rely on a range of individuals to act on their behalf; these include employees, directors, partners, and a range of professional agents. An action performed by an agent on behalf of the principal will be deemed to be an action by the principal. An agent will obtain fees for services rendered according to the contractual reward structure offered by the principal which may incorporate a performance-related element.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.4

        Profits generated are distributed to the Muwakkil less the Wakil fee, in accordance with the terms of the Wakalah agreement. In case the contract includes some "indicative" or "expected" profit rate on the investment, the Wakalah contract can include a clause stipulating that the Wakil's remuneration may be:

        (a) A pre-agreed flat fee; or
        (b) A certain share of profit added to a pre-agreed flat fee, subject to the terms and conditions.
        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.5

        A Wakalah financing can be carried out on either:

        (a) A restricted basis, where the capital provider allows the Wakil to make investments subject to specified investment criteria or certain restrictions such as types of instrument, sector or country exposures etc.; or
        (b) An unrestricted basis, where the capital provider allows the Wakil to invest funds freely based on the latter's skills and expertise. For interbank Wakalah, the Wakil is permitted by the Muwakkil to invest the investment amount on a discretionary basis, but only in Shari'a-compliant transactions.
        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.6

        As the Muwakkil, the Islamic bank licensee is exposed to the risk of losing its invested capital — that is, capital impairment risk. Any loss on the investment is to be borne solely by the Muwakkil, but is limited to the amount of its capital. Losses that are due to fraud, misconduct, negligence or breach of contractual terms are to be borne by the Wakil. The Wakil shall be entitled to any pre-agreed flat Wakil fee irrespective of whether the actual profit is less than, equal to or greater than any expected profit, and also in the event of a loss.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.7

        However, while it is not permissible for a Wakil to give a guarantee against losses or for any indicative or expected profits, such a guarantee may be given by a third party on the basis of tabarru' (donation). In such a case, the amount of the Wakalah capital so guaranteed may be considered as subject to credit risk with a risk-weighting equal to that of the guarantor. In particular, such guarantees may be given when liquid funds are placed in an Islamic interbank market under a Wakalah contract.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.8

        In the absence of any fraud, misconduct, negligence or breach of contractual terms on the part of Wakil, all the risk of loss on the investment is to be borne by the Muwakkil. Therefore, the Islamic bank licensee is exposed to the skills of the Wakil that manages the investments on behalf of the Islamic bank licensee, as well as to business risks associated with the underlying activities and types of investments or assets of the Wakalah agreement.

        January 2015

    • Capital Requirements

      • CA-3.10.9

        For the purpose of determining the minimum capital requirements, this section makes distinctions between the following main categories of Wakalah:

        (a) Wakalah investments to undertake trading activities in foreign exchange, shares and/or commodities, including Commodity Murabaha Transactions (CMTs);
        (b) Wakalah investments with a private commercial enterprise to undertake business activities (other than (a) above); and
        (c) Wakalah placement in the interbank market.
        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.10

        The Wakalah exposures, are measured net of specific provisions as set out below.

        January 2015

    • Wakalah Investments to Undertake Trading Activities in Foreign Exchange, Shares and/or Commodities, including CMT

      • CA-3.10.11

        The RW is based on the applicable underlying assets as set out in the market risk section in Chapter CA-5. An investment in foreign exchange and trading in gold or silver must be measured according to the treatment as set out in Section CA-5.5, which requires an 8% capital charge on the greater of either net long or net short positions and an 8% capital charge on the net position of gold/silver.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.12

        The RW of a Wakalah for funds that are invested in quoted shares must be measured according to the equity position risk approach, where positions in assets tradable in markets qualify for treatment as equity position risk in the trading book, which incur a total capital charge of 16% (equivalent to 200% RW) as set out in Section CA-5.3.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.13

        Investment in commodities must be measured according to either the maturity ladder approach or the simplified approach as set out in Section CA-5.6.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.14

        If the Wakalah investment is to be utilised by the Wakil (another Islamic bank licensee) for conducting CMT to earn a (fixed rate of) profit, the investing Islamic bank licensee is primarily exposed to the counterparty risk. In that case, the invested amount (net of specific provisions) must be assigned a RW based on the credit standing of the counterparty as rated by an approved ECAI. In cases where the counterparty is unrated, a RW of 100% applies (see Section CA-4.2).

        January 2015

    • Wakalah Investments with Private Commercial Enterprise to Undertake Business Activities (other than in Paragraph CA-3.10.11)

      • CA-3.10.15

        This type of Wakalah investment exposes the Islamic bank licensee to capital impairment risk. Due to this downside risk, the RW is measured according to equity position in the banking book approach. The RW must be applied to the exposures net of specific provision, if any.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.16

        As explained in Sections CA-3.6 and 3.7, there are two possible methods used to calculate the equity exposures, that is:

        (a) The simple risk-weight method; and
        (b) The slotting method.
        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.17

        The RW under the simple risk-weighting method (a) entails a RW of 300–400%. Under the slotting method (b), an Islamic bank licensee must map its RW into four supervisory categories as described in Appendix CA-5 (specialised financing) where the RWs of each category are as follows:

        Supervisory Categories Strong Good Satisfactory Weak
        Risk weights 90% 110% 135% 270%

        The above RWs under the slotting method for specialised financing include an additional fixed factor of 20% RW to cater for potential decline in the Wakalah net asset value.

        For further explanation, also see Paragraphs CA-4.8.7 to 4.8.11.

        January 2015

    • Wakalah Placement in the Interbank Market

      • CA-3.10.18

        An Islamic bank licensee may place liquid funds with a central bank or another Islamic bank licensee on a Wakalah basis in order to obtain a return on those funds. Such placements are considered to be more secure than those identified in Paragraphs CA-3.10.11 to CA-3.10.14, owing to the available credit standing of, and the established relationship with, the counterparty in the interbank market.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.19

        A placement of funds made by an Islamic bank licensee with another Islamic bank licensee under a Wakalah agreement (whether on a restricted or unrestricted basis) may be subject to a Shari'a-compliant guarantee from a third party. Such a guarantee can be related to the amount of principal invested, as well as the expected return. In such cases, the capital must be treated as subject to credit risk, with a risk weighting equal to that of the guarantor provided that the RW of that guarantor is lower than the RW of the Wakil as counterparty. Otherwise, the RW of the Wakil applies. As explained in Section CA-3.11 related to Mudarabah interbank placement, interbank placement received on a Wakalah basis can also be effectively treated as a liability by the Islamic bank licensee receiving the funds. In the absence of any guarantee mentioned earlier, the risk-weighting must be applied based on the credit standing of the counterparty as rated by an approved ECAI, or a RW of 100% for an unrated counterparty.

        January 2015

      • CA-3.10.20

        If the funds placed under a Wakalah arrangement are placed in a foreign currency, in addition to the above treatment, capital charge related to foreign exchange risk is applicable as outlined in Section CA-5.5.

        January 2015

    • Summary of Capital Requirements for Wakalah Categories

      • CA-3.10.21

        The following table sets out the Wakalah categories that attract capital charges.

        Wakalah Category Credit RW Market Risk Capital Charge
        Wakalah investments to undertake trading activities in foreign exchange, shares and/ or commodities, including CMT Not applicable Depends on the underlying asset as set out in the applicable market risk section.

        See Section CA-5.5 for Wakalah investments in FX.

        See Section CA-5.3 for Wakalah Investments in shares.

        See Section CA-5.6 for Wakalah Investments in commodities.

        See Section CA-3.11 for Wakalah investments in CMT.
        Wakalah investments with private commercial enterprise to undertake business activities, other than above categories
        (a) Simple risk-weight method 300–400% RW of the placed amount less any specific provisions

        Or:
        (b) Slotting method Between 90% and 270% RW of the contributed amount to the business venture based on the four categories
        Not applicable
        Wakalah placement in the interbank market Risk-weighting can be applied based on the credit standing of the counterparty* as rated by the approved ECAI, or a RW of 100% for an unrated counterparty. Not applicable**

        * In the case of a third-party guarantee, the capital must be treated as subject to credit risk with a risk weighting equal to that of the guarantor provided that the RW of that guarantor is lower than the RW of the Wakil as counterparty. Otherwise, the RW of the Wakil applies.

        ** If funds are invested in foreign exchange, foreign exchange risk will also be applicable as per Section CA-5.5.

        January 2015